Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Peyton Snyder's avatar

I'll have to look into this book. In university I did a few research papers about 19th-20th c. migration to the Americas---not just the US, but also Canada and Brazil, two countries that opened their doors to much of the world after America started to close theirs in the 1920s. From everything I read, it seemed to me that immigrants and their descendants were much more likely to retain their original language in Canada and Brazil than they were in the US, even into the third generation and beyond. And indeed, there are more policies on the books protecting immigrant languages in Canada and Brazil than in the US, though it's nowhere near as robust as what you see with minority language protections in Europe. Though xenophobia cropped every once in a while in Brazil and Canada, it seems to have had much more currency in US politics throughout the era. In any case, openness to immigrant cultures strikes me as very wise policy, at least from an economic standpoint, if for no other reason. A multilingual/immigrant labor force facilitates foreign commerce in a way that's sort of hard to overstate, if you look at some of the data that's out there. Of course, on a "vibes" level, it's also just much more interesting to live in a multicultural setting like that. Though I suppose that's a matter of opinion.

Expand full comment
1 more comment...

No posts